Sparkling Water Without PFAS or BPA: Cans, Glass and Plastic, Brand by Brand (2026)
The 30 Second Summary
- Sparkling water carried more PFAS than still water when Consumer Reports tested both in 2020. Seven of twelve sparkling waters came in above its 1 ppt line, against two of thirty five still waters.
- The numbers have fallen since. Every sparkling water figure published after 2021 sits under 4 ppt in total, the limit EPA set for a single PFAS in tap water, and the brand that led in 2020 is now a third of where it was.
- The can is lined with plastic, and the lining is the BPA question. Health Canada found BPA in every canned soft drink it could measure and essentially none in the same drinks in glass or plastic. A few brands put their lining in writing; most say nothing.
- Our pick is LaCroix Pure, carbonated water and nothing else in a can its maker says has been made without BPA liners since 2019. Liquid Death Sparkling Mountain Water is the same idea from a mountain spring.
- For flavor, Spindrift Raspberry Lime names its fruit on the label instead of hiding it behind "natural flavors", and had the lowest PFAS total of any sparkling water Consumer Reports found it in.
- To keep plastic out of the water path entirely, make it at home in the Aarke Carbonator Pro, a steel machine that carbonates filtered tap water in a glass bottle with no electricity.
What Consumer Reports Found
In September 2020 Consumer Reports published the test this whole question starts from. It bought 47 bottled waters, twelve of them carbonated, sent two to four samples of each to an accredited lab blind, and counted 30 PFAS compounds in every one. The result was lopsided. Only two of the 35 still waters came in above the 1 part per trillion of total PFAS that some experts treat as the line. Seven of the twelve sparkling waters did, and the single highest reading in the whole test, 9.76 ppt, came from a sparkling mineral water.
Nobody has shown why. A researcher quoted by Consumer Reports suggested the carbonation, the source water or treatment that stops short of 1 ppt, and those are hypotheses rather than findings. What the test does establish is that sparkling water was worth asking about separately, and that the answer differed a great deal from one brand to the next: from nothing detected to almost ten parts per trillion across drinks that look identical in a glass.
What the Tests Since Then Show
The brand at the top of that chart is the clearest case of a number moving. Consumer Reports bought three fresh samples after its maker said it had upgraded its filtration, and published 3.9 ppt in February 2021, down from 9.76. Mamavation's 2025 screen of fifteen sparkling drinks, run to EPA Method 1633 for 40 compounds, read the same water at 2.8 ppt. Every sparkling water figure published since 2021 sits under 4 ppt in total, which is the limit EPA set in 2024 for a single compound, PFOA or PFOS, in the water that comes out of a tap.
FDA ran its own sampling in 2023 and 2024 and found none of 18 PFAS above reporting limits near 0.3 ppt in any of the 23 carbonated waters it tested. That sounds like the end of it and is not, because FDA's 18 compounds leave out the two Mamavation found most. 6:2 FTS turned up in seven of its nine positive drinks, and PFBA, a short chain compound, made up half the figure on the highest one. A method that does not look for a compound cannot report it.
So the honest summary is a small number that is real. Every recent figure sits under the limit EPA now applies to a single compound in tap water, and the brand that measured highest in 2020 has come down by more than two thirds. The differences between brands are also real, and they are why the table below carries every figure we could find rather than a single pass or fail.
Holding a can you are not sure about? Product Check holds our verdict on over 1,000 brands, with the label, the container and every test behind each one.
Seltzer Is Not Legally Bottled Water
This is the detail that surprises people most. FDA's standard for bottled water, the rule that sets its contaminant limits, explicitly excludes anything sold as carbonated water, seltzer, soda water, sparkling water or tonic water. Those are regulated as soft drinks. A drink sold as mineral water or sparkling bottled water from a protected source is covered, which is why the European mineral waters are held to the arsenic and lead limits and a can of flavored seltzer is not.
Neither category has a PFAS limit. FDA says on its own PFAS page that it is working on one for bottled water. The bottled water industry's trade association holds its members to 5 ppt for one compound and 10 ppt for several, which binds members only. Massachusetts is the one state we found that screens carbonated drinks for PFAS before licensing the plant. For everything else, a published independent test is the only check there is, which is why the next three sections are about what the container adds rather than what the source contains.
What Lines a Can
An aluminum can is never bare aluminum on the inside. Carbonated water is mildly acidic and would corrode the metal, so every beverage can is sprayed inside with a thin plastic coating, and the drink touches that coating rather than the can. For decades it was an epoxy made from BPA. The replacements, sold as BPA NI for "not intentionally added", are mostly acrylic and polyester systems, and almost no drink brand names which one it uses.
The switch is further along than it was and not finished. Ball, the largest can maker in the world, reported 58 percent of its inside coatings BPA NI in 2023 and 72 percent of its cans in 2025, which leaves roughly one can in four still lined the old way. The other two big makers publish no figure at all. Europe banned BPA in can coatings from January 2025. The United States has no restriction.
The measurements are consistent. When Health Canada tested 72 canned soft drinks it found BPA in every one it could measure, mostly under 0.5 micrograms per liter, and when it compared the same drinks by package, the canned versions carried BPA and the glass and plastic versions essentially did not. A 2025 crossover trial in 103 women found urinary BPA 22 percent higher after a week of drinking from cans than from plastic bottles. Migration rises with time, heat and acidity, so a flavored seltzer stored warm is the worst case.
What to do with that is simple. A brand that states its lining contains no BPA has put a claim in writing that can be checked; a brand that says nothing has told you nothing. Four of the brands in the table below have made that statement, and our can picks are among them. A statement is not a test, and no laboratory has published a bisphenol measurement of any sparkling water can we cover, so a cool cupboard rather than a hot garage still matters.
Glass, and the Part Nobody Names
Glass is the material everyone reaches for, and the glass itself puts nothing into water. The cap is another matter. In 2025 the French food safety agency ANSES counted microplastics in drinks sold in France and found glass bottles the most contaminated: about 100 particles per liter in glass bottled colas, lemonades and beers, five to fifty times what the same drinks carried in cans or plastic. The particles matched the paint on the outside of the metal caps, scratched as the caps rubbed together in storage. Water was the cleanest drink tested, at 4.5 particles per liter in glass against 1.6 in plastic.
Under the paint, every metal cap has a plastic liner pressed against the bottle's mouth to hold the gas in. The Ecology Center pulled 273 caps from glass bottled drinks in 2021 and identified each liner by infrared. More than a third of brands used a liner plasticized with phthalates, mostly sodas. The sparkling waters were cleaner: no PVC and no phthalates, but several of their caps were a polystyrene copolymer, a styrene based plastic we treat as a caution in contact with water, and others were PEVA, a polyolefin we do not. Most makers do not name the liner, so for most glass bottles you are buying a part nobody will describe.
One more glass detail. Green and brown glass get their color from metal oxides, and Lead Safe Mama's XRF has read lead in the green glass of a well known Italian mineral water bottle at 146 ppm. That is a reading of the bottle wall, not of the water, and nobody has measured what reaches the water from it. We record it and score it, because a container is part of what you are drinking from.
Plastic Bottles
A plastic bottle is the only container where the whole wall in contact with the drink is plastic, and sparkling water is harder on it than still. When Mason and colleagues counted particles in water from the same German spring in two formats, the plastic bottle averaged 1,410 particles per liter and the glass bottle 204. Microscopy that can see nanoplastics puts bottled water at around 240,000 particles per liter, most of them too small for older methods to count.
Carbonation adds a chemical cost. PET is made with an antimony catalyst, and a Hungarian study of mineral waters found more antimony in sparkling than in still water stored for the same time, while a 2021 study of 50 PET bottled drinks, warmed for a week, found that the more acidic the drink, the more antimony moved into it. Every plastic bottled sparkling water in our table reads skip, and that applies to the big bottles of brands whose cans pass.
The Brands at a Glance
Four questions decide a sparkling water here. Does the label name everything in it. What touches the water, and has the maker said what it is. What has an independent lab measured. And has a regulator, a court or a recall had anything to say about it.
| Brand | What touches the water | PFAS measured | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cans | |||
| LaCroix PureOnly carbonated water | Can lining, made without BPA since 2019 by the maker's statement | 1.16 ppt (CR 2020) | Our pickFlavored LaCroix is careful: "naturally essenced" names nothing |
| Liquid Death SparklingArtesian water, CO2 | Can lining, "no BPAs" by the maker's statement | Not yet tested | Our pick |
| SpindriftWater and named fruit juice | Can lining, BPA NI by the maker's statement | 0.19 ppt Raspberry Lime (CR 2020); 2.62 ppt Grapefruit (Mamavation 2025) | Our pick |
| San Pellegrino cansMineral water only | Can lining, not named | 0.31 ppt (CR 2020); 0.81 ppt (Mamavation 2025) | PassesNot picked because the lining is not named |
| Polar SeltzerOriginal is carbonated water only | Can lining, not named | 6.41 ppt (CR 2020), disputed by the maker | CarefulOriginal can passes; flavors careful, bottles skip |
| bublyCarbonated water, natural flavor | Can lining, not named | 2.24 ppt Blackberry (CR 2020) | CarefulUnflavored just bubly passes |
| WaterlooCarbonated water, natural flavors | Can lining, BPA NI by the maker's statement | 0.91 ppt Strawberry (Mamavation 2025) | Careful |
| AHACarbonated water, natural flavors | Can lining, not named | Not tested | Careful |
| Coca-ColaCaramel color, natural flavors | Can lining; the company's Canadian FAQ said it uses BPA | Not tested | Careful |
| Glass | |||
| GerolsteinerMineral water, natural CO2 | Polystyrene copolymer cap liner | None found by FDA (2023 to 2024) or Mamavation (2025) | Careful |
| Topo ChicoMineral water, CO2 | Polystyrene copolymer liner in the 12 oz cap | 9.76 ppt (2020), 3.9 (2021), 2.8 (2025) | Careful |
| San Pellegrino glassMineral water only | PEVA cap liner; lead read in the green glass | As the cans | Careful |
| PerrierMineral water, CO2 | Cap liner not named | 1.1 ppt (CR 2020); 1.8 ppt (Mamavation 2025) | Careful |
| Mountain Valley SparklingSpring water, CO2 | Polystyrene copolymer cap liner | None found in a flavored bottle (Mamavation 2025) | Careful |
| Saratoga SparklingSpring water, CO2 | Cap liner not named | Not tested | Careful |
| Plastic bottles | |||
| Any sparkling water in PETPolar, Gerolsteiner, Topo Chico, San Pellegrino, Perrier | The plastic bottle itself | As each brand above | Skip |
| PeñafielMexican mineral water | The plastic bottle itself | Not tested; arsenic 18.1 ppb (CR 2019) | Skip |
| Made at home | |||
| Aarke Carbonator ProYour own filtered water | Glass bottle, stainless nozzle and cap, silicone seal | Whatever your filter leaves | Our pick |
| SodaStreamYour own filtered water | Glass carafe on the E-Duo; a plastic bottle on every other model | Whatever your filter leaves | CarefulThe glass carafe E-Duo passes; it is a plastic bodied electric machine |
What We Would Buy
Our picks meet one bar the rest of this table does not: a label that names everything in it, and a maker who has said in writing that its can lining contains no BPA, or no can at all. Among those, owner reviews decide the order.
LaCroix Sparkling Water, Pure
Carbonated water and nothing else, in a 12 ounce aluminum can the maker states has been made without BPA liners since April 2019. Treated by reverse osmosis.
Liquid Death Sparkling Mountain Water
Artesian mountain water and CO2, the whole label, in an aluminum can whose maker states no BPA is used in the lining. Tallboy and 12 ounce sizes.
Spindrift Sparkling Water, Raspberry Lime
Carbonated water, raspberry purée and lime juice, with no "natural flavors" umbrella. Aluminum can with a BPA NI liner by the maker's statement. 0.19 ppt PFAS in 2020.
Aarke Carbonator Pro
Stainless steel body and nozzle, a dishwasher safe glass bottle, a steel cap and a silicone seal. No plastic in the water path, no electricity. Takes standard 60 liter CO2 cylinders.
LaCroix Pure is the top pick because it is the plainest product on the shelf with the plainest answer about its can. The label reads "only carbonated water", the company told the press in 2019 that every can made for it since April that year has been made without a BPA liner, and it carries thousands of owner reviews at 4.7 stars. Its 2020 PFAS figure, 1.16 ppt, sat just over Consumer Reports' line and well under every limit anyone has written, and a 2025 screen of the lime flavor found a single compound under 1 ppt. Buy the Pure. The flavored cans add an essence the label does not explain.
Liquid Death is the pick if you want spring water rather than treated water. Its sparkling line is artesian water and CO2 and nothing else, and its maker says in writing that no BPA is used in the can lining. No published test covers the plain sparkling can, so it carries no number either way. Spindrift is the flavored pick because it is the only big seltzer that names its fruit rather than hiding it behind "natural flavors". One caveat in the same breath: Mamavation's 2025 screen found 2.62 ppt of one compound in the grapefruit flavor, the highest single reading in that round, so the raspberry lime, at 0.19 ppt in 2020, is the one we would buy.
A carbonator only carbonates what you put in it. The Aarke Carbonator Pro takes plastic out of the water path completely, which no can or cap does, but the PFAS question then moves to your tap. Pair it with a filter certified for PFAS, such as the ones in our water filter guide.
The Picks Side by Side
| Pick | Label | Container | Trade off |
|---|---|---|---|
| LaCroix Pure | Carbonated water | Can, no BPA liner since 2019 | Replacement coating not named |
| Liquid Death Sparkling | Artesian water, CO2 | Can, no BPA by the maker's statement | No published PFAS test yet |
| Spindrift Raspberry Lime | Water, raspberry, lime | Can, BPA NI liner | Fruit makes it acidic, so store it cool |
| Aarke Carbonator Pro | Your own water | Glass and stainless steel | Costs more up front; needs a good filter |
Brands We Did Not Pick
Topo Chico
The mineral water topped Consumer Reports' 2020 test at 9.76 ppt total PFAS and has come down since, to 3.9 ppt in 2021 and 2.8 ppt in Mamavation's 2025 screen, made up of PFBA and 6:2 FTS. A California Proposition 65 case over PFOA in the water was settled in 2023 with a treatment protocol, revised in March 2026. In May 2025, 16.9 ounce glass bottles were recalled for Pseudomonas bacteria.
The 12 ounce glass bottle's cap liner was identified as a polystyrene copolymer, the plastic bottles carry the particle finding every PET water does, and the flavored versions add natural flavors. The Colección cans, which are filtered water with three named mineral salts rather than the Monterrey source, pass our checks; the lining is not named.
Polar Seltzer
Consumer Reports measured 6.41 ppt total PFAS in Polar's original seltzer in 2020, the second highest of the twelve sparkling waters it tested, and Polar disputed how the total was calculated. It now says its water is treated by reverse osmosis to undetectable PFAS, and the laboratory reports it posts, which it commissioned, show no detectable lead, arsenic, cadmium or mercury. The PFAS report its own paperwork asks for is not among them. Polar says nothing about its can lining. The original can passes our checks on what is recorded; the flavors use natural flavors and the plastic bottles read skip.
Perrier
Nestlé admitted to the French government in 2021 that water at the Perrier source in Vergèze had been treated with ultraviolet light and activated carbon, both prohibited for anything sold as natural mineral water, and a French Senate report in May 2025 set out how. Regional health authorities blocked 9,534 pallets in 2025 after bacteria were found in testing, and a Paris fraud investigation searched the plant in May 2026. A US class action filed in 2024 challenges the mineral water claim; we could not establish where it stands. Consumer Reports measured 1.1 ppt in 2020 and Mamavation 1.8 ppt in 2025, including 0.25 ppt of PFOA.
Gerolsteiner
This is the hard one. Gerolsteiner has the best PFAS record of any sparkling water we looked at: FDA found none of 18 compounds in four samples in 2023 and 2024, and Mamavation found none in the glass bottle in 2025. But the Ecology Center identified its cap liner as a polystyrene copolymer, a plastic we treat as a caution against water, and in March 2025 two lots of the 750 ml glass bottle were recalled because they could crack. The plastic bottle is a skip: 1,410 particles per liter in one lot against 204 in glass from the same spring.
Coca-Cola and AHA
Coca-Cola's Canadian consumer FAQ, as archived in January 2024, said "We use BPA in the linings of our beverage cans". Its US pages name no lining for any can. Coca-Cola Classic adds caramel color, phosphoric acid and natural flavors, has three old Proposition 65 notices naming it and two 2025 can recalls for plastic and metal fragments. AHA, the company's flavored sparkling water, is carbonated water and natural flavors in a can whose lining is not named.
bubly and Waterloo
Both are carbonated water and natural flavors, an umbrella term that can stand for any number of compounds and that we count against a label wherever it appears. Consumer Reports measured 2.24 ppt in bubly Blackberry in 2020, and bubly was the only brand above the 1 ppt line that did not answer when asked. PepsiCo names no lining. Waterloo does state a BPA NI liner, which puts it closer to a pick than anything else here; the flavors are what keep it out. Unflavored just bubly passes our checks.
Peñafiel
Consumer Reports' 2019 arsenic investigation found the unflavored mineral water averaging 18.1 ppb across three samples, above FDA's 10 ppb limit for bottled water, and the maker's own retest found about 17. It was withdrawn in June 2019 and is back on sale with no independent retest since. A 2022 California consent judgment bars sales there above 5 ppb. Every Peñafiel product comes in plastic, and the flavored ones add corn syrup and natural and artificial flavors.
Drinking It With Less Exposure
- Buy cans from a brand that states its lining, and store them somewhere cool. Bisphenol migration in cans rises with time and heat, and flavored drinks are more acidic than plain.
- Pick plain over flavored. Plain sparkling water is less acidic, and a label that reads one or two ingredients has nothing to hide behind.
- Add the fruit yourself. A squeeze of lime in a glass costs nothing and is the only flavor whose ingredients you know completely.
- Never leave a plastic bottle in a hot car. Heat drives antimony and particles out of PET faster than anything else.
- If you carbonate at home, filter first. A carbonator removes nothing. Use a filter certified for PFAS reduction, then carbonate in glass.
- Keep a glass bottle upright. The cap liner is the plastic in the bottle, and a bottle stored upright keeps the water off it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does sparkling water have PFAS in it?
Some does, in small amounts. Consumer Reports' 2020 test found PFAS above 1 part per trillion in seven of twelve sparkling waters, against two of thirty five still waters, with the highest at 9.76 ppt. Every figure published for a sparkling water since 2021 has been under 4 ppt in total, the limit EPA set for a single compound in tap water, and FDA's 2023 to 2024 sampling found none of the 18 compounds it looks for in 23 carbonated waters. The method matters: a 2025 screen for 40 compounds found traces in nine of fifteen drinks.
Do sparkling water cans have BPA in the lining?
Some still do, and most brands do not say. Every beverage can is coated inside with a thin plastic lining. The old one was a BPA epoxy, and the largest can maker reported 72 percent of its cans on a replacement in 2025, which leaves about a quarter that were not. A few sparkling water brands state that their cans are made without BPA linings, and those are the brands we pick. The US places no restriction on BPA in cans; Europe banned it from January 2025.
Is sparkling water in glass better than cans?
Not automatically. The glass puts nothing into the water, but the metal cap has a plastic liner pressed against the bottle, and most makers do not name it; several sparkling water liners identified by lab were a polystyrene copolymer. French testing in 2025 also found glass bottled drinks carried more microplastics than canned or plastic bottled ones, from paint scratched off the caps, although water was the cleanest drink in every container. A can from a brand that states a BPA free lining is at least as good a choice.
Why did sparkling water test higher for PFAS than still water?
Nobody has shown why. The explanations offered are the carbonation process, the source water, and treatment that does not take PFAS below 1 part per trillion, and none has been tested. Many sparkling waters are mineral waters, which may only be lightly treated, while many still waters are purified by reverse osmosis, and a 2021 Johns Hopkins study found purified bottled water carried significantly less PFAS. A 2024 study of 112 bottled waters found PFAS levels differed between mineral and purified water, but not between still and sparkling.
Is making sparkling water at home cleaner?
It can be the cleanest option, with one condition. A carbonator that uses a glass bottle and a steel nozzle keeps plastic out of the water path entirely, which no can, cap or plastic bottle can claim. But it removes nothing from the water you put in, so the PFAS question moves to your tap. Filter the water first with a filter certified for PFAS reduction. Machines that carbonate in a plastic bottle bring the plastic back, and the bottle carries an expiry date for a reason.
Is flavored sparkling water worse than plain?
Usually a little. Most flavored seltzers list "natural flavors" or a "natural essence", which can stand for any number of compounds and tells you nothing about what is in the can. Fruit and citric acid also make the drink more acidic, and acidity pulls more out of a can lining or a plastic bottle. A brand that names its actual fruit is the exception worth paying for, or add a slice of lemon to plain water yourself.
Is seltzer regulated like bottled water?
No. FDA's bottled water standard explicitly excludes anything sold as carbonated water, seltzer, soda water, sparkling water or tonic water, so those drinks are not held to its contaminant limits at all. Products sold as mineral water or sparkling bottled water from a protected source are covered. Neither has a PFAS limit: FDA says it is working on one for bottled water, and the industry trade association applies its own 5 and 10 ppt limits to members only.
Related Articles
- Best Water Filters for Microplastics and PFAS
The filters certified to take PFAS out before you carbonate anything. - Microplastics in Bottled Water
Why the plastic bottle is the biggest source, still or sparkling. - The Plastic Inside Your Glass Jar Lid
The same hidden liner, under the lid of every jar in the pantry. - BPA Free Is Not Safe
What replaced BPA, and why the label is a claim rather than a test. - What Are PFAS?
Forever chemicals, explained from the start.